Why Female Athletes are 8x More Likely to Tear Their ACL

In a devastating turn of events, USC's sophomore sensation Juju Watkins suffered an ACL injury during their Sweet 16 matchup against Mississippi State. The injury occurred during the first quarter, leaving the Trojans without their leading scorer. USC now faces a similar challenge to UConn, who had to adapt their gameplay following Paige Bueckers' and Azzi Fudd’s previous ACL injuries. Paige came back to play last year and dropped 40 points in UConn’s recent Sweet 16 matchup against Oklahoma, and I know Juju will also come back stronger than ever. The Trojans faced an elite 8 rematch with UConn without Juju and unfortunately couldn't pull out the win for her. A very sad way to end the season.

The high prevalence of ACL injuries among female athletes has been a growing concern in sports medicine. According to Dr. Christina Allen, chief of Yale Sports Medicine, women athletes are 2-8 times more likely to experience ACL tears compared to their male counterparts. This disparity is attributed to several factors, including anatomical differences in hip and knee alignment, hormonal influences, and neuromuscular control patterns. A sports physician noted women's wider pelvises and different landing mechanics contribute significantly to this increased risk.

Research published in the Journal of Sports Medicine indicates that female athletes often demonstrate different neuromuscular activation patterns during high-risk movements like jumping and cutting (common movements in basketball, lacrosse, soccer, etc). This emphasizes the critical importance of targeted training programs that address these gender-specific biomechanical factors. Physical therapists, sports teams, sports medicine pros, and former athletes are at the forefront of advocating for more studies done on women specifically, early intervention, and preventive training, particularly during adolescent years when these movement patterns are being established.

Lots of big words above, but let's break down the nuts and bolts in common terms: ACL injuries take a long time to heal, often impacting the career and athletic development of athletes who have spent years playing at the top of their game. Some athletes never return to the game, and risk losing opportunities to play at the college and pro levels due to stiff competition and the limited space on team rosters who are constantly chasing championships.

The recovery process for an ACL injury typically spans 6-9 months, though some athletes may need up to a year to return to competitive play. The timeline varies based on injury severity, overall fitness level, and dedication to rehabilitation protocols. Approximately 80-85% of athletes return to their sport following ACL reconstruction. However, only about 65% return to their pre-injury level of performance. Athletes who return to high-level competition often require additional time for mental preparation and confidence building. Many sports medicine programs now incorporate psychological support and specialized return-to-play protocols to address both the physical and mental aspects of recovery.

ACL Injury Prevention Tips

For women engaged in fitness and recreational sports (likely many of you reading this), maintaining proper form during exercise is not just about maximizing results - it's crucial for injury prevention. When lifting weights or performing high-impact activities, focus on mastering fundamental movements before increasing intensity or weight. Pay special attention to your core engagement, hip alignment, and knee positioning during squats, lunges, and jumping movements. Start each workout with a proper warm-up that includes dynamic stretching and mobility exercises. Listen to your body's signals and avoid pushing through sharp or unusual pain. Consider working with a certified trainer initially to learn correct form and technique, as this investment in proper training can prevent years of potential injury-related setbacks. Consistency with good form is more valuable than lifting heavier weights or performing exercises with compromised technique.

These recommendations are based on guidelines from the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) and the National Athletic Trainers' Association (NATA).

For more resources you can visit:

• American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons - Comprehensive ACL injury prevention guidelines

• American College of Sports Medicine - Sport-specific training protocols

• National Athletic Trainers' Association - Injury prevention resources and educational materials

• STOP Sports Injuries - Free prevention programs and educational resources

As Juju Watkins begins her journey to recovery, her injury serves as a crucial reminder of the ongoing need for improved injury prevention protocols in women's sports. While the immediate focus is on USC's tournament prospects, the broader conversation about female athlete safety and injury prevention must continue to evolve. With advancing research, better training protocols, and increased awareness, the sports medicine community is making strides in understanding and addressing these gender-specific challenges. The development and implementation of targeted prevention programs, combined with early education and proper training, will be essential in reducing ACL injury rates among female athletes and ensuring their long-term success in sports.

I hope you spend time in nature this week, and enjoy the final games of the college women’s basketball season!

If you enjoyed this article, please consider sharing it with someone else who may like it.